Proprietor / Bartender – Alex Andres
Leon Czolgosz – Gene A. Johnson
John Hinckley – David Bubien
Charles Guiteau – Jeff Hall
Guiseppe Zangara – John Walko
Samuel Byck – Stephen Catanzarite
Lynette “Squeaky” Fromme – Seana Simon
Sara Jane Moore – Sandy Reigel
John Wilkes Booth – Michael Cavalier
Balladeer – Jeff Lagios
David Herold / James Blaine / Hangman – Benjamin Simon
Emma Goldman – Brittany Duffy
James Garfield – Justin Indovinat
Warden – Adam Truszkowski
Billy – Alex Fattore
Lee Harvey Oswald – Matthew Udvari
Bystanders, Fairgoers
Lara Cottrill
Justin Indovina
J. D. Maxwell
Josh McConaughy
Elizabeth O’Donnell
Jen Panko
Katie Shenot
Benjamin Simon
Adam Truszkowski
Orchestra
Conductor – Donald McKinney
Flute – Susan Hayden, Anita Mensch
Clarinet – Jamie Antonazzo, Jessica Willard
Saxophone – Don Davis, Ryan Tamburrino
Trumpet – Mark Custer, Eric Greco
Trombone – David Haffey, Christine Ceratti
Piano – Marissa Ulmer
Percussion – Matt Stanton, Jamie Shee
Keyboards – Christine Murphy, Rob Montini