Proprietor / Bartender – Alex Andres

Leon Czolgosz – Gene A. Johnson

John Hinckley – David Bubien

Charles Guiteau – Jeff Hall

Guiseppe Zangara – John Walko

Samuel Byck – Stephen Catanzarite

Lynette “Squeaky” Fromme – Seana Simon

Sara Jane Moore – Sandy Reigel

John Wilkes Booth – Michael Cavalier

Balladeer – Jeff Lagios

David Herold / James Blaine / Hangman – Benjamin Simon

Emma Goldman – Brittany Duffy

James Garfield – Justin Indovinat

Warden – Adam Truszkowski

Billy – Alex Fattore

Lee Harvey Oswald – Matthew Udvari

Bystanders, Fairgoers

Lara Cottrill

Justin Indovina

J. D. Maxwell

Josh McConaughy

Elizabeth O’Donnell

Jen Panko

Katie Shenot

Benjamin Simon

Adam Truszkowski

Orchestra

Conductor – Donald McKinney

Flute – Susan Hayden, Anita Mensch

Clarinet – Jamie Antonazzo, Jessica Willard

Saxophone – Don Davis, Ryan Tamburrino

Trumpet – Mark Custer, Eric Greco

Trombone – David Haffey, Christine Ceratti

Piano – Marissa Ulmer

Percussion – Matt Stanton, Jamie Shee

Keyboards – Christine Murphy, Rob Montini